Take an inept college student (who's been suspended) and coax him into babysitting the children next door, even though he has no clue as to what to do with them. Who wouldn't want him for a sitter? Jonah Hill (How to Train Your Dragon, Reno 911!) is Noah Jaybird, a babysitter in training who takes on the challenge of handling these monstrous children of neighbor Mrs. Pedulla for just one night.ou know how everything goes wrong no matter how good you try to be? That's happening for Noah on this night as he's invited to a party with the intention of having sex with his dream girl, Stephanie (Dreama Walker from Gossip Girl, The Good Wife). Then he scares the kids off when a couple of psychopathic druggies take him on a wild chase all around the town. ids are capably played by the studious and serious Slater (played by Max Records of Where The Wild Things Are), Kevin Hernandez plays Rodrigo a foreign exchange student living with the Pedulla's, and the wild child of the family Blithe (Landry Bender). It's a rather dark comedy due to not too bright actions of the sitter (obtaining drugs so his girlfriend can get high).